The Nature of Opals
Opals are unlike any other gemstone. Known for their shifting color and internal depth, they have a distinctive presence that can feel almost alive. They’re also frequently misunderstood, imitated, or misrepresented.
Understanding how to identify real opals begins with knowing how they form, the range of natural types, and how authentic stones differ from synthetic or dyed alternatives.
What Makes an Opal an Opal?
Unlike crystalline stones, opals form when silica-rich water settles into rock cavities over long periods of time. As the water evaporates, microscopic silica spheres remain. When light passes through these spheres, it creates the stone’s characteristic play of color—often called “fire.”
Because this structure is organic and irregular, no two opals are ever identical. Color shifts with movement and light, and patterns vary widely depending on formation, origin, and stone composition.
Common Types of Natural Opals
Opals are found in several regions around the world, each producing stones with distinct characteristics. The following are some of the more commonly encountered types, though they represent only a portion of naturally occurring opals.
Australian Opals
Often considered the classic opal, these stones range from white to dark body tones and display a wide spectrum of color play.
Ethiopian Opals
Typically lighter in appearance with vibrant flashes of color. These opals are more porous and may respond differently to moisture and wear.
Boulder Opals
Formed within ironstone, these opals retain portions of their host rock, creating bold contrast and natural texture.
Mexican Fire Opals
Known for their warm body color—ranging from yellow to deep orange or red—Mexican fire opals may display play of color or appear translucent without it. Their glow comes from body tone rather than surface flash alone.
These examples highlight the diversity of natural opals, though many additional varieties exist depending on region and formation.
Synthetic, Dyed, and Imitation Opals
Not all opals on the market are natural.
Synthetic opals are lab-created stones designed to mimic the structure and appearance of natural opal. They often display highly uniform patterns and intense, evenly distributed color.
Dyed or imitation opals may be made from glass, resin, or other materials and treated to resemble opal. Bright, saturated colors—such as vivid hot pinks or neon tones—are often indicators of dyed or imitation stones rather than naturally occurring opal.
Unlike natural opals, these materials lack internal depth. Their color tends to sit on the surface and remain static rather than shifting with movement and light.
How to Identify Real Opals
Authentic opals display depth rather than surface shimmer. Their color play appears layered, changing subtly as the stone moves rather than repeating the same pattern.
Common indicators of natural opal include:
-
Irregular, non-repeating patterning
-
Variation in color intensity across the stone
-
A solid, mineral feel rather than glassy smoothness
Uniform appearance, identical stones repeated across multiple pieces, or overly saturated colors can signal synthetic or imitation materials.
How Gypsy Jewels Works with Opals
At Gypsy Jewels, we work exclusively with real opals. Many of the opals used in our work are cut in-house from raw stone, allowing us to select, shape, and finish each piece with intention.
Working directly with raw material ensures transparency in sourcing and allows the stone’s natural character to guide the final design. Variations in color, pattern, and intensity are embraced as part of the material itself rather than minimized or altered.
Each opal is chosen for its individual presence, not uniformity.
Choosing Opals with Intention
The most reliable way to identify real opals is to purchase from makers who are transparent about sourcing, materials, and process. Understanding the type of opal, how it’s formed, and how it’s meant to be worn allows you to appreciate the stone for what it is—dynamic, expressive, and inherently one of a kind.
— From the Gypsy Jewels studio in West Texas